Why Are Tom Thumb Bits Bad

Why Are Tom Thumb Bits Bad? (Explained!)

I’ve found that bit selection is a crucial aspect of horse riding, as it directly affects the communication and comfort between rider and horse. 

One controversial bit that often sparks heated debates among equestrians is the Tom Thumb bit.

Now, you might be wondering, what exactly is a Tom Thumb bit? 

We’ll look at this later on in the article, but for now, let me answer a simple question: Why are tom thumb bits bad?

Tom Thumb bits are often considered bad or controversial due to their design, which incorporates a jointed mouthpiece and short, straight shanks. This design can create pressure points in a horse’s mouth, causing discomfort, confusion, and potential injury due to the leverage and severity of the bit’s action.

Well, let’s delve into this issue and explore why there’s such contention surrounding their use.

Why Are Tom Thumb Bits Bad? (Key Takeaways)

  • Tom Thumb bits can create pressure points in a horse’s mouth due to their jointed mouthpiece and short, straight shanks, leading to potential discomfort and injury.
  • The design of Tom Thumb bits can cause confusion in communication between the rider and the horse due to the bit’s action and lack of precise signals.
  • These bits operate with leverage, which, combined with their severity, can lead to amplified pressure on the horse’s mouth, potentially causing pain and resistance.
  • Tom Thumb bits may not be effective for training purposes due to their potential to cause discomfort, leading to adverse behaviors in horses.
  • The design of Tom Thumb bits has sparked controversy in the equestrian community, with many professionals and riders expressing concerns about their use.
  • Due to their potential to cause pain and discomfort, many horse trainers and professionals advise against using Tom Thumb bits for effective and humane communication with horses.
  • Riders and trainers often explore more suitable, gentle, and effective bit options that prioritize the horse’s comfort and responsiveness while maintaining communication and control.

A Controversial Choice for Equine Communication

Why Are Tom Thumb Bits Bad

The Tom Thumb bit is a type of leverage bit commonly used in horse riding. 

It consists of a jointed mouthpiece with shanks attached to it.

These shanks are designed to create leverage when pressure is applied by the rider through the reins. 

At first glance, this design may seem harmless or even appealing due to its aesthetically pleasing appearance and availability in various styles.

However, despite its popularity, the use of Tom Thumb bits has stirred significant controversy within the equestrian community. 

Many riders argue that these bits can compromise effective communication with our equine companions while potentially causing discomfort or pain.

The Tension Between Tradition and Modernity

The controversy surrounding Tom Thumb bits stems from conflicting viewpoints on traditional versus modern training methods. 

Some riders uphold traditional horsemanship practices that have been passed down through generations, including the use of leverage bits like the Tom Thumb. 

They argue that when used correctly by skilled riders with gentle hands, these bits can provide subtle cues and aid in establishing clear communication with horses.

On the other side of the debate are those who advocate for more modern approaches rooted in scientific understanding of equine behavior and anatomy. 

They assert that newer designs such as snaffle bits or milder curb bits offer more direct communication between rider and horse while minimizing potential discomfort or confusion.

This clash between tradition and modernity has created a polarized discourse, making it essential to delve deeper into the specific characteristics of Tom Thumb bits and explore the potential issues they present. 

By doing so, we can evaluate whether these concerns are valid or merely rooted in misunderstandings or misapplications.

The Anatomy of a Tom Thumb Bit

When examining a Tom Thumb bit, it becomes apparent that its design is quite distinct. 

It consists of a jointed mouthpiece connected to short shanks on either side.

The mouthpiece typically has a central joint that allows for flexibility and movement. 

This joint is often connected to long, flat bars that rest against the horse’s tongue when pressure is applied through the reins.

Moving down, we find the shanks, which extend vertically from either side of the mouthpiece. 

These shanks are where the reins attach and serve as levers to amplify pressure applied by the rider’s hands.

Comparison To Other Types Of Bits

In contrast to other bits like snaffles or milder curb bits, Tom Thumb bits tend to have more severe actions. 

While snaffles work through direct pressure on the horse’s mouth with no leverage effect, Tom Thumb bits rely heavily on leverage to communicate with the horse. 

This leverage amplifies rein aids, making them stronger and potentially harsher for the horse.

Additionally, unlike traditional snaffles that have a simple jointed mouthpiece or curb bits with solid bars and port options for tongue relief, Tom Thumb bits incorporate both elements into one design. 

This combination creates unique challenges in terms of communication and comfort for the horse.

Watch this:


The Potential Issues with Tom Thumb Bits

Tom Thumb bits, with their leveraged action, present a fundamental issue when it comes to direct communication between rider and horse. 

The leverage design reduces the rider’s ability to provide clear and precise cues to the horse.

Unlike a direct-action snaffle or a curb bit with shorter shanks, the Tom Thumb bit introduces an additional lever arm that can muddle the signals sent by the rider’s hands. 

This lack of direct communication can lead to confusion for the horse, making it difficult for them to understand what is being asked of them.

Limited Sensitivity Due To Leverage Action

The leverage action of Tom Thumb bits results in limited sensitivity for both rider and horse. 

When pressure is applied through the reins, it gets multiplied due to the longer shanks.

Consequently, even slight movements from the rider’s hands can result in amplified pressure on the horse’s mouth. 

This reduced sensitivity can hinder subtle communication between horse and rider, leading to misunderstandings or overreactions from the horse.

Inconsistent Pressure on Horse’s Mouth

One of the significant concerns associated with Tom Thumb bits is their potential for inconsistent pressure on the horse’s mouth. 

Due to their jointed mouthpiece design and long shanks, these bits exert uneven pressure across different parts of the mouth when rein aids are applied.

The jointed mouthpiece creates several points where pressure can be unevenly distributed, possibly causing discomfort or pain in sensitive areas like bars and tongue. 

Additionally, when reins are pulled back sharply or abruptly, there is a risk of pinching or squeezing effect as these bits rotate in the horse’s mouth.

Potential for Discomfort or Pain in Horse’s Mouth

Tom Thumb bits have been heavily criticized for their potential to cause discomfort or pain in a horse’s mouth. 

The jointed mouthpiece, combined with the leverage action, can create pressure points that may lead to irritation or soreness. 

Additionally, the longer shanks of these bits can cause pinching and rubbing against the horse’s lips and corners of the mouth when rein aids are applied.

This discomfort can negatively impact a horse’s willingness to accept contact with the bit and can even result in behavioral issues such as head tossing or evading contact. 

Watch this:


Inappropriate Use by Inexperienced Riders

One of the major issues with Tom Thumb bits stems from inexperienced riders who lack a deep understanding of proper rein aids. 

These riders may unknowingly apply incorrect pressure or use inconsistent signals, leading to confusion for the horse.

Without a clear and consistent communication system between rider and horse, the desired response becomes muddled. 

In some cases, riders may unintentionally pull on the reins unevenly or with excessive force, causing discomfort or even pain for the horse.

Lack of Understanding Regarding Proper Rein Aids

A common misconception among inexperienced riders is that using a Tom Thumb bit requires nothing more than pulling back on the reins to slow down or stop their horses. 

However, proper rein aids involve much more finesse and subtlety than simply yanking back on the reins.

Understanding how to use your hands, seat, and legs in conjunction with the bit is essential for effective communication with your equine partner. 

Unfortunately, many inexperienced riders lack this crucial knowledge and inadvertently rely solely on brute force when using Tom Thumb bits.

Incorrect Application Causing Confusion for the Horse

The improper application of Tom Thumb bits can lead to confusion and frustration for horses. 

These bits have both direct pressure on the bars of the mouth and leverage action that exerts pressure on other parts of their head.

When used incorrectly, such as pulling only one rein at a time or applying inconsistent pressure, horses struggle to understand what their rider wants them to do. 

This confusion can result in resistance, disobedience, or even dangerous behaviors as horses seek relief from discomfort caused by conflicting signals.

Ill-Fitting and Poorly Adjusted Bits

An ill-fitting or poorly adjusted Tom Thumb bit exacerbates any existing problems associated with its design. 

It is vital to consider the comfort and effectiveness of the bit for the horse. 

A bit that is too large or too small can cause discomfort, pain, or even injury.

Additionally, improper adjustment of the bit can create increased severity in its action. 

For instance, if the shanks are set at an incorrect angle or if the curb chain is too tight, even subtle movements of the reins can result in amplified pressure on sensitive areas of the horse’s mouth and head.

Importance of Correct Sizing for Comfort and Effectiveness

Proper bit sizing is fundamental for both comfort and effectiveness. 

When it comes to Tom Thumb bits, finding the right fit is crucial to minimize potential issues. 

The width of the mouthpiece should allow a small amount of space on either side when placed in the horse’s mouth without pinch points or excessive movement.

The length and angle of the shanks should be appropriate for your horse’s level of training and sensitivity. 

Taking precise measurements and seeking professional advice ensures that you select a bit that fits your horse comfortably without causing unnecessary discomfort.

Improper Adjustment Leading to Increased Severity

The correct adjustment of a Tom Thumb bit plays a significant role in determining its severity. 

Inexperienced riders may overlook adjusting important components such as curb chains or keepers properly.

If not adjusted correctly, these elements can amplify pressure and make signals more severe than intended by increasing leverage action. 

This improper adjustment not only compromises communication between rider and horse but also adds unnecessary discomfort and potential pain to an already problematic design.

Watch this:


Alternatives to Tom Thumb Bits

When it comes to choosing a bit for your equine companion, it’s crucial to consider their comfort and communication. 

Thankfully, there are a plethora of alternatives to the contentious Tom Thumb bits that can offer a more gentle approach while still maintaining effective control.

One popular option is the snaffle bit. 

Snaffles feature a simple design with a jointed mouthpiece and direct pressure on the horse’s mouth, making them suitable for horses of all experience levels.

They provide clear signals to the horse, promoting responsiveness and allowing for precise communication between rider and steed. 

Additionally, milder curb bits can be considered as an alternative if your horse requires additional leverage but without excess severity.

How Different Bit Designs Can Suit Individual Horses’ Needs

Every horse is unique and may have specific preferences or requirements when it comes to their bitting equipment. 

Different bit designs cater to these diverse needs by offering variations in pressure application and severity levels.

For instance, some horses may benefit from a French-link snaffle that eliminates the nutcracker effect often associated with single-jointed snaffles. 

This design provides increased comfort by reducing tongue pressure and encouraging relaxation in the mouth.

On the other hand, horses that require slightly more control without compromising sensitivity may find relief in certain types of mild curb bits such as a Kimberwicke or a Myler combination bit. 

These designs incorporate innovative features like independent side movement or multiple rein options, allowing for customized adjustments based on individual requirements.

Remember, choosing an appropriate bit should always involve considering your horse’s conformation, level of training, temperament, and responsiveness rather than solely relying on tradition or convenience. 

By understanding these alternatives and appreciating their benefits tailored to individual equines’ needs, we can prioritize the welfare and communication with our equine companions.

Why Are Tom Thumb Bits Bad? Conclusion

After delving into the world of horse bits, it becomes evident that Tom Thumb bits can pose several problems. 

The lack of direct communication between rider and horse due to the leverage action limits sensitivity and creates inconsistency in pressure on the horse’s mouth. 

Additionally, the potential for discomfort or pain arises from pressure points caused by jointed mouthpieces and shanks, as well as the pinching or squeezing effect when reins are pulled. 

Horses are not mere instruments at our disposal; they are intelligent creatures deserving of our respect and care. 

As equestrians, it is our responsibility to prioritize their comfort and well-being above all else.

Choosing a bit that promotes effective communication while minimizing potential harm is crucial. 

Opting for gentler alternatives like snaffles or milder curb bits can provide more comfort to our equine partners. 

Related Articles:



Are tom thumb bits harsh?

Yes, Tom Thumb bits are often considered harsh due to their design, which can create pressure points in a horse’s mouth, potentially causing discomfort and confusion in communication between the rider and the horse.

How to fit a tom thumb bit:

When fitting a Tom Thumb bit, ensure it allows one to two wrinkles at the corners of the horse’s mouth without causing discomfort. Proper fitting is crucial to prevent potential pain or irritation.

Tom thumb bit with copper rollers?

Tom Thumb bits with copper rollers have rotating elements intended to offer mild stimulation, but the overall design may still pose issues related to pressure points and leverage.

What is a tom thumb bit used for?

Tom Thumb bits are used in riding as a type of bit that provides control and direction for the horse. However, they are controversial due to their potential to cause discomfort.

Can you put a Tom thumb bit on bridle?

A Tom Thumb bit is commonly attached to the bridle and is used in horse riding, yet its design and function have raised concerns about its harshness and potential for discomfort.

What is a Tom thumb snaffle bit?

The term “Tom Thumb snaffle bit” is a misnomer; the Tom Thumb bit is not a true snaffle due to its shank and leverage action, which differentiates it from traditional snaffle bits.

What are the worst bits for horses?

Bits like the Tom Thumb, due to their potential to create discomfort, confusion, and pressure points, are often considered among the worst bits for horses by some equestrians.

Why are gag bits bad?

Gag bits can be considered problematic due to their severity and potential to cause injury or discomfort in a horse’s mouth, creating an unyielding effect on the poll and mouth.


I have a Masters degree in Communication and over 5 years working in PR. I have a wife and four children and love spending time with them on our farm. I grew up on a farm with cows, sheep, pigs, goats, you name it! My first childhood pet was a pig named Daisy. In my spare time, I love holding bbq parties for my friends and family

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *